A Taste of 1918 in 2025

Finally, we’re sending our most delicious, best-selling baked goods on the road! These recipes started delighting taste buds in the early 1900s and had a beach resurgence in the 21st century. Baked with love (and butter!), sink your teeth into the Hamptons’ favorite desserts.

Cookies & Cakes, oh my!

Mix and match your perfect holiday gift box. Three bags of cookies or 2 bags of cookies and a banana cake. So many decisions! Send one to a friend or a frenemy, a teacher or a student, a grandparent or a grandchild … anyone who appreciates cookies that are crisp on the edge and soft in the middle. Or the decadent indulgence of chocolate chips melted into banana cake.

Build Your Holiday Box

Our Story

The size of my grandma Bunny’s heart was only rivaled by the size of her recipe box — and I’ve dusted off her most well-loved cards. Throwing it back to the early 1900s, especially in the kitchen, reminds us that real ingredients, working by hand, and a little patience are methods that stand the test of time.

The mouthwatering idea for My Bunny Baked Goods began on the beach in Montauk in 2020 and has since crept into neighboring Hamptons towns. Our best-selling cookies are quickly becoming a summer staple, and our moist, chocolate-chip-studded banana cake punctuates every meal or beach outing.

Now we’ve expanded more than our waistline — we’re growing our footprint, bringing our cookies and cakes from Montauk to your home. We’re starting simple, with our Holiday Gift Box, but stay tuned for more to come soon...

Frequently Anticipated Questions

Only the best ingredients

Chocolate chip cookies: 

Ingredients: Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips (Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin [an Emulsifier], Natural Flavor), All-Purpose Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Butter (cream, natural flavor, salt), Brown Sugar, Sugar, Eggs, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Soda.

Contains: Milk, Eggs, Soy, Wheat.

Banana cake with chocolate chips: 

Ingredients: Sugar, Bananas, All-Purpose Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Salted Butter (Cream, Salt), Eggs, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips (Sugar, Chocolate, Cocoa Butter, Milk Fat, Soy Lecithin [an Emulsifier], Natural Flavor), Sour Cream (Cultured Cream, Enzymes), Vanilla Extract, Baking Soda, Salt.

Contains: Milk, Eggs, Soy, Wheat.

Baked in a facility that also processes dairy and nuts.

Where can I purchase?

Here, of course!

If you’re visiting the East End, these stores carry a variety of baked goods from our kitchen. Most are seasonal stores but Balsam Farms and Bennett Shellfish stay open most of the year, so pop in when you’re around.

Balsam Farms (Amagansett only) @balsamfarms

Gosman’s Fish Market @gosmansfish

Duryea’s Market @duryeasmontauk

Spring Close Farm @springclosefarm

Bennett’s Shellfish @bennett.shellfish

Share the Harvest @sharetheharvestfarm

Corporate orders? Yessiree!

Please email jill@mybunnybakedgoods.com to arrange orders of 10+ Holiday Gift boxes and/or if you would like custom labels or messaging.

Some shipping information

Choose your ship date (not to be confused with arrival date!) on the order form. 

  • Standard Shipping within the continental US is included! We ship via UPS, 2-3 days depending on zone. Please email for arrangements to other locations, or for overnight pricing, or in-person delivery in the 5 boroughs of NYC or Long Island.
  • Please DO NOT ship to a PO Box, as your package may not arrive or may not arrive in a timely manner!
  • As of now, there are 3 designated SHIPPING DATES: December 2, 9 & 16. Order forms will be closed at 6 pm the night prior to the shipping date. (So place your orders by 6 pm on December 1, 8 & 15).

What about returns?

All orders are FINAL, so please make your order and check it twice before you send it through!

Get busy making your cookie and cake selection so we can get busy baking!

Customize Your Holiday Box

Talk to Us

Contact us with any questions, comments, custom orders, or just to say hi!